The promise that isn’t a guarantee
Two monthly devotions, two private revelations, and what they do and don’t promise.
Check the parish bulletin and you may spot extras on the first Friday and first Saturday of the month: Exposition, Confession, an extra Mass. These two devotions sit side by side in the bulletin, but they come from different centuries.
First Fridays come from St Margaret Mary Alacoque, a Visitation nun at Paray-le-Monial in France, who reported visions of the Sacred Heart in the 1670s. Her writings include what became known as the ‘Great Promise’: that those who receive Communion on nine consecutive first Fridays will receive the grace of final repentance. Friday was already the obvious day, the day of the Passion. Margaret Mary was canonised in 1920.
First Saturdays come from Fatima. On 10 December 1925, Sister Lucia, the eldest of the three Fatima visionaries, reported a vision of Mary at her convent in Pontevedra, Spain. It asked for Confession, Communion, five decades of the Rosary and fifteen minutes of meditation on the first Saturday of five consecutive months, in reparation to the Immaculate Heart. Saturday had long been Mary’s day: Alcuin, Charlemagne’s scholar, already assigned a Saturday Mass in her honour in the 700s. The local bishop approved the First Saturdays in 1939.
Both rest on private revelations. The Catechism explains that such revelations, even when approved, do not belong to the deposit of faith and do not add to Christ’s revelation; they help people live it more fully in a particular time (CCC 67). So the promises are encouragements to conversion, not guarantees that work automatically.
Nine Fridays, five Saturdays. Simple to count, and much harder to do faithfully, which is rather the point.
Why it matters
Behind both devotions are central truths. The Heart of Jesus is a symbol of his love for every human person (CCC 478). Saturday honours Mary’s faith on the ‘great Saturday’, when she alone among the disciples kept vigil in hope while the Lord lay in the tomb (Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy, 188). And both devotions are built around Confession and Communion, the ordinary means of grace.
Claims checked
- The First Fridays devotion comes from St Margaret Mary’s revelations in the 1670s.Recorded
- The First Saturdays devotion was requested in a 1925 vision at Pontevedra.Recorded
- Saturday was a day for Mary long before Fatima.Recorded
- The Church teaches that completing nine First Fridays guarantees salvation.False
Sources to check
- Aleteia, ‘5 Things to Know About First Saturdays’Explains the 1925 Pontevedra vision and the five First Saturdays.
- Catholic Encyclopedia, ‘Special Devotions for Months’Background on the Sacred Heart devotion approved in the 19th century.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 67The Church’s teaching on private revelations and their limits.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 478The Sacred Heart as the sign of Christ’s love.
- Congregation for Divine Worship, Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy (2001), n. 188Why Saturday honours Mary: her vigil of faith on Holy Saturday.
- University of Dayton Marian Library, ‘Saturday Devotions’Alcuin’s votive Masses, with Saturday assigned to Mary.
- Shrine of Fatima, ‘First Saturdays Devotion’Confirms the Bishop of Leiria approved the devotion on 13 September 1939.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
The Church teaches that making nine First Fridays guarantees salvation.
Show the answer
Myth. The promise comes from a private revelation; the Church does not treat such promises as guarantees (CCC 67).