Bite-size Formation

The Eleventh Hour

How the Church keeps time

The Eleventh Hour › Bite 17 of 34 · 2 min read

Was Jesus born ‘before Christ’?

A humble monk invented our year numbers, skipped year zero, and probably got the date wrong.

First recorded: 525. Roots: Easter tables and the ‘era of Diocletian’
In the year: Mary, Mother of God; civil New Year (1 January)

Every time you write the year, you are using a system invented in 525 by a monk in Rome named Dionysius Exiguus, ‘Dennis the Little’ or ‘the Humble’. He was extending a set of Easter tables. Those tables counted years from the accession of Emperor Diocletian, the great persecutor of Christians. Dionysius preferred not to honour a persecutor, so he counted ‘from the Incarnation of our Lord Jesus Christ’ instead. Anno Domini, the year of the Lord, was born.

It did not catch on immediately. The great populariser was the English monk Bede, whose Ecclesiastical History of the English People (731) used AD dates consistently. Bede even counted backwards for events before Christ, describing Julius Caesar’s invasion of Britain as happening in the sixtieth year before the Incarnation. Through Bede and Charlemagne’s court, AD dating spread across Europe.

There is no year zero. The count runs straight from 1 BC to AD 1, because medieval Europe did not use zero as a number. That means the third millennium technically began on 1 January 2001, not 2000, as the pedants at your millennium party correctly pointed out.

Dionysius probably got the birth year wrong. Matthew’s Gospel places Jesus’ birth during the reign of Herod the Great, and most historians, following Josephus, date Herod’s death to around 4 BC. That would put the Nativity around 6 to 4 BC, a few years ‘before Christ’. Some scholars argue for a slightly later date for Herod’s death, so this is Plausible rather than settled.

And ‘Common Era’ is not a twenty-first-century invention. Scholars, including the astronomer Johannes Kepler, used the Latin equivalent of ‘vulgar era’ in the seventeenth century, and Jewish scholars adopted ‘Common Era’ in the nineteenth. Whatever you call it, the year count is a monk’s Easter table.

Why it matters

Counting from the Incarnation is itself a confession of faith: Christ stands at the centre of history. At the Easter Vigil, the priest traces the numerals of the current year on the paschal candle and prays, ‘Christ yesterday and today, the Beginning and the End… All time belongs to him, and all the ages’ (Roman Missal, Easter Vigil). John Paul II began Dies Domini with the same words (Dies Domini 1).

Claims checked

Sources to check

Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.

Myth or fact?

There was no year 0 between 1 BC and AD 1.

Show the answer

Fact. Dionysius and Bede counted from 1; zero was not used as a number in medieval Europe.