Why 25 December
The Gospels give no date. Two theories, both alive.
Read every Gospel account of Christ’s birth and you will find shepherds, magi, a manger and a census, but no date. Early Christians were curious. Around 200, Clement of Alexandria reports Egyptian Christians proposing several dates, including one in May (Stromata 1.21). There was clearly no settled tradition at that point.
The earliest firm record of 25 December comes from Rome. A richly illustrated almanac known as the Chronograph of 354 includes a list of martyrs’ burial dates compiled around 336. Its first entry reads, in effect: ‘eighth day before the Kalends of January: Christ born in Bethlehem of Judea’. That is 25 December. In the East, many churches kept 6 January as the Nativity instead.
Why 25 December? Two main theories are still debated. The first, the ‘history of religions’ theory, notes that Emperor Aurelian had promoted the cult of the Unconquered Sun, and the same Chronograph lists a solar festival on 25 December. On this view, Christians deliberately celebrated the true Sun of Justice on the day of the sun. The second, the ‘calculation’ theory, notes that around 200 Tertullian already equated the day of the crucifixion with 25 March, and a later tradition held that Christ was conceived on that same date; Augustine mentions it (On the Trinity 4.5). Add nine months to 25 March and you reach 25 December. Many scholars now think both factors played a part. Both get a Plausible.
What does not hold up is the claim that Christmas was simply placed on the Saturnalia. That Roman festival ran from 17 to 23 December. Some festive customs may have rubbed off over time, but the dates do not match, so ‘Christmas was set on the Saturnalia’ is False.
A southern-hemisphere footnote: in Rome, 25 December sits beside the winter solstice, when the sun begins to return. Here in Australia it falls just after the longest day, so the symbolism runs the other way round, and the Sun of Justice arrives in the full heat of summer.
Why it matters
Whichever theory is right, the meaning is the same: the Word became flesh at a real moment in history (Jn 1:14; CCC 461). The ‘sun’ imagery is biblical before it is Roman. Malachi foretells that ‘the sun of righteousness shall rise, with healing in its wings’ (Mal 4:2), and Zechariah’s song greets the day that ‘shall dawn upon us from on high’ (Lk 1:78), a canticle the Church sings every morning at Lauds.
Claims checked
- The Gospels do not give a date for Christ’s birth.Recorded
- The earliest record of 25 December is in a Roman list from about 336.Recorded
- 25 December was chosen to replace a festival of the Unconquered Sun.Plausible
- 25 December was calculated as nine months after a 25 March conception.Plausible
- Christmas was placed on the Roman Saturnalia.False
Sources to check
- Clement of Alexandria, Stromata 1.21Shows Egyptian Christians around 200 proposing several dates for Christ’s birth, so there was no fixed tradition.
- Chronograph of 354, Depositio Martyrum (Latin text)The Roman almanac containing the earliest record of 25 December as Christ’s birth.
- Augustine, On the Trinity 4.5Augustine reports the tradition that Christ was conceived and suffered on 25 March.
- Andrew McGowan, ‘How December 25 Became Christmas’, Biblical Archaeology SocietyAccessible summary by an Australian scholar of both theories on how 25 December was chosen.
- Thomas Talley, The Origins of the Liturgical Year (1986)Standard scholarly study of how the Christian calendar developed, including Christmas.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 461The Incarnation: the Son of God assuming human nature.
- John 1:14; Malachi 4:2; Luke 1:78The Word made flesh, and the biblical images of Christ as rising sun and dawn.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
The earliest surviving record of Christmas on 25 December dates from the 4th century.
Show the answer
Fact. It appears in a Roman list from about 336, preserved in the Chronograph of 354.