Why Easter wanders
A moon, a council and a quarrel older than the creed.
Christmas sits on its date like a well-behaved guest. Easter wanders across thirty-five days, anywhere from 22 March to 25 April. The reason is that Easter is tied to the Passover, and the Passover is dated by the moon.
The earliest arguments were not about the moon but about the day of the week. In the second century, the churches of Asia Minor kept Easter on 14 Nisan, the date of the Passover, whatever day of the week it fell on. Rome and most other churches always kept it on a Sunday. Around 155, Polycarp of Smyrna visited Pope Anicetus in Rome; they could not agree, so they celebrated the Eucharist together and agreed to differ. Around 190, Pope Victor threatened to excommunicate the Asian churches, and Irenaeus wrote to tell him, in effect, to calm down (Eusebius, Church History 5.23–25).
The Council of Nicaea in 325 settled the main principle: all churches would celebrate Easter on the same Sunday. By then the holdouts were no longer in Asia Minor but in Syria, Cilicia and Mesopotamia, whose churches, as Athanasius later recalled, ‘kept the feast at the same season as the Jews’. But here is the surprise. Contrary to popular belief, none of Nicaea’s canons sets out the famous rule ‘the first Sunday after the first full moon after the spring equinox’. The council’s decision is known from letters, including Constantine’s letter recorded by Eusebius. The Catechism summarises the outcome in those familiar terms (CCC 1170), which is fair as a description of what the bishops agreed to aim for; but the formula itself appears in no canon. The detailed method of calculation, the computus, was worked out by Alexandria and adopted gradually: in the Latin West through tables like those of Dionysius Exiguus (525), and in England only after the Synod of Whitby (664).
Even the ‘full moon’ is not the one in the sky. The Church uses an ‘ecclesiastical moon’ from tables, with the equinox fixed at 21 March. Easter is calculated, not observed. Since the Gregorian reform of 1582, East and West use different calendars, which is why Orthodox Easter often falls on a later date.
In Australia, the ‘spring equinox’ of the formula is our autumn equinox. So eggs, chicks and spring lambs, all symbols of new life, arrive here as the leaves are falling.
Why it matters
Why argue over a date? Because Easter is the ‘Feast of feasts’ (CCC 1169), and keeping it on different days divides Christians at the very heart of their faith. That is why Nicaea sought one date, why the Catechism notes that the Churches are seeking agreement so as to celebrate the Resurrection on a common date again (CCC 1170), and why the Second Vatican Council declared itself open to a fixed Sunday for Easter if other Christians agreed (Sacrosanctum Concilium, Appendix).
Be in the room. In Was There a Time?, you play a bishop on the road to Nicaea, and when the council takes up the date of Easter, you’ll be asked where your town stands.
Claims checked
- Western Easter can fall on any date from 22 March to 25 April.Recorded
- Churches in Asia Minor kept Easter on 14 Nisan in the 2nd century.Recorded
- By Nicaea, the churches out of step were in Syria, Cilicia and Mesopotamia.Recorded
- The Catechism summarises Nicaea’s agreement as the full-moon rule (CCC 1170).Recorded
- Nicaea’s canons set out the ‘first full moon after the equinox’ rule.Legend
- Easter is calculated from tables, not from the observed moon.Recorded
Sources to check
- Eusebius, Church History 5.23–25Eusebius tells the second-century Easter quarrels, including Polycarp, Anicetus, Victor and Irenaeus.
- Eusebius, Life of Constantine 3.18–20Constantine’s letter after Nicaea asking all churches to keep Easter on the same day.
- Athanasius and the bishops of Egypt, Letter to the Bishops of Africa (Ad Afros), 2Recalls that the churches of Syria, Cilicia and Mesopotamia kept Easter ‘at the same season as the Jews’, one reason the council met.
- Bede, The Reckoning of Time (725)Bede’s handbook on calculating Easter, which spread the method in the West.
- Gregory XIII, Inter gravissimas (1582), English translationThe 1582 bull reforming the calendar to keep Easter in step with the spring equinox.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 1169–1170Easter as ‘Feast of feasts’; the Catechism’s summary of Nicaea and the search for a common date.
- Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963), AppendixThe Council’s openness to a fixed date for Easter, in agreement with other Christians.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
The Council of Nicaea wrote the rule ‘first Sunday after the first full moon after the equinox’ into its canons.
Show the answer
Myth. Nicaea agreed on a common Sunday. The detailed calculation was worked out later from Alexandrian methods.