Bite-size Formation

The Eleventh Hour

How the Church keeps time

The Eleventh Hour › Bite 14 of 34 · 2 min read

Why the Church abolished an hour of prayer

Fifteen centuries of prayer, ended in one sentence.

First recorded: c. 420s. Roots: John Cassian’s monastery at Bethlehem; suppressed by Vatican II in 1963
On the clock: 06:30 Prime, the first hour

For about fifteen hundred years, monks, nuns and clergy prayed an hour called Prime at the first hour of the day, around 6 am. Then, in 1963, the Second Vatican Council abolished it in one short sentence: “The hour of Prime is to be suppressed” (Sacrosanctum Concilium 89d). Few liturgical changes have been so brief.

Where did Prime come from? John Cassian, writing in the 420s, describes a new morning office introduced ‘in our own time’ in his old monastery at Bethlehem (Institutes 3.4). His explanation is wonderfully human. After the long night office, some monks went back to bed and slept until the third hour. The elders added a new office at sunrise, and that was the end of the lie-in. Prime, in other words, may have begun life as an alarm clock.

Scholars still debate whether Cassian’s ‘new office’ really is what later became Prime, so that part earns a Plausible rather than a Recorded. What is certain is that Benedict included Prime in his Rule a century later, and from there it spread through the Western Church. Over time it gathered extra elements: the reading of the martyrology, the assigning of the day’s work, and prayers for the dead.

Why drop it? By the twentieth century Prime overlapped heavily with Lauds, the morning office. The Council wanted each hour to be prayed at its true time and to mean something distinct, and two morning hours back to back did not fit that aim. Morning Prayer absorbed Prime’s job, and the 1971 Liturgy of the Hours has no first hour at all.

Prime is not entirely extinct, though. Communities that use the 1962 Breviary still pray it, as do some monastic houses with their own approved books. So the hour invented to get monks out of bed is still, here and there, getting them out of bed.

Why it matters

The reform turned on a principle: each hour should be prayed at its true time, so that the whole day is made holy. The Council asked for the traditional sequence of hours to be restored so that they relate once again to the time of day at which they are prayed (SC 88), and the Catechism describes the Liturgy of the Hours as the way the mystery of Christ permeates and transfigures each day (CCC 1174).

Claims checked

Sources to check

Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.

Myth or fact?

The Second Vatican Council abolished one of the traditional hours of prayer.

Show the answer

Fact. Sacrosanctum Concilium 89(d) suppressed the hour of Prime.