Bite-size Formation

The Eleventh Hour

How the Church keeps time

The Eleventh Hour › Bite 1 of 34 · 2 min read

Why tomorrow starts tonight

Genesis puts evening first, and the Church’s great days still do.

First recorded: Ancient Israel. Roots: Gen 1:5; Lev 23:32; carried into Christian Evening Prayer I
On the clock: 18:00 Sunset: Sundays and solemnities begin
In the week: Sunday begins on Saturday evening, with Evening Prayer I
In the year: Christmas begins at Evening Prayer I (24 December, evening)

Open the first page of the Bible and listen to the refrain: “And there was evening and there was morning, one day” (Gen 1:5). Evening first. For the writers of Genesis a day did not begin with the alarm clock. It began as the light faded.

Israel kept time that way. The Day of Atonement was to be kept “from evening to evening” (Lev 23:32), and Jewish families still welcome the Sabbath at sundown on Friday. The Gospels take it for granted. In Capernaum the crowds wait until evening, after sunset, before carrying their sick to Jesus (Mk 1:32), because once the sun had gone down the Sabbath was over and carrying was allowed again. On Good Friday the bodies had to come down from the crosses before sunset, when the Sabbath began (Jn 19:31).

The Church inherited this instinct, but only partly, and here is the twist. Officially, the Church’s liturgical day runs from midnight to midnight, exactly like the civil one. The 1969 Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year and the Calendar say so in plain terms (n. 3). The exception is reserved for the days that matter most. Sundays and solemnities begin the evening before, with Evening Prayer I, traditionally called First Vespers. That is why a Sunday has two Evening Prayers and an ordinary Tuesday has only one.

So the Church keeps two clocks. The everyday one, shared with the Romans who counted from midnight, runs the ordinary weekdays. The older one, shared with Israel, starts the great days at dusk. Christmas Eve and the Easter Vigil are not warm-up acts. Liturgically, they are the feast itself, already under way.

This also explains a whole family of English words: Christmas Eve, New Year’s Eve, All Hallows’ Eve. An ‘eve’ is not the day before the party. It is the party starting on time.

So next time someone complains that Christmas starts too early, you may gently agree with them. It starts the night before, and it has done so for a very long time.

Why it matters

Beginning the great days at dusk is more than an inherited habit. It gives every feast the shape of Christ’s own Passover: a passage from darkness into light. The Catechism calls the Easter Triduum the ‘source of light’ for the whole year (CCC 1168). And Evening Prayer echoes the psalm the Church sings at dusk: ‘let… the lifting up of my hands [be] as an evening sacrifice’ (Ps 141:2), giving thanks for the day and looking forward in hope.

Claims checked

Sources to check

Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.

Myth or fact?

Officially, the Church’s liturgical day runs from midnight to midnight.

Show the answer

Fact. The Universal Norms (n. 3) set midnight to midnight. Only Sundays and solemnities begin the evening before.