Is Halloween really pagan?
Rome and the Franks chose 1 November, not the Celts.
Every 31 October, someone at the school gate announces that Halloween is really a pagan festival in disguise. Start with the name. ‘Halloween’ is a contraction of ‘All Hallows’ Even’, the eve of All Saints, recorded in sixteenth-century Scotland. So Halloween is, quite literally, a Catholic vigil.
Before there was a 1 November feast, there were commemorations of all the martyrs. In the East, a feast of all martyrs was kept around Pentecost, and the Byzantine Churches still keep All Saints on the Sunday after Pentecost. In Rome, Pope Boniface IV dedicated the Pantheon, once a temple to all the gods, to Mary and all the martyrs on 13 May in 609 or 610.
The 1 November date has a Roman and Frankish trail. Pope Gregory III (731–741) dedicated an oratory in St Peter’s to all the saints. In 835, Pope Gregory IV, with the support of the Frankish emperor Louis the Pious, extended a 1 November feast of All Saints across the Frankish lands, and from there it spread.
Now the famous claim: the Church chose 1 November to Christianise Samhain, the Celtic festival marking the start of winter. The records point another way. The decisive moves happened in Rome and the Frankish empire, not in Ireland. Early Irish calendars, the Martyrology of Tallaght and the Félire Óengusso (c. 800), kept a feast of all the saints of Europe on 20 April. They do treat 1 November, the day of Samain, as a day crowded with saints, but a clear ‘All Saints’ on that date appears in Irish calendars only later. Historians such as Ronald Hutton argue that the date was not chosen with Samhain in mind. So the strong claim is a Legend. That some later Halloween folk customs in Ireland and Scotland drew on older seasonal traditions is Plausible.
The next day, 2 November, is All Souls. The abbot Odilo of Cluny ordered his monasteries to pray for all the faithful departed on that day around 998, and the custom spread throughout the Church. As we saw earlier, it is one of only two days on which a priest may celebrate three Masses.
Why it matters
All Saints and All Souls together express two articles of the Creed: the communion of saints and prayer for the dead. The saints in glory, the faithful on earth and those being purified form one Church, sharing their spiritual goods (CCC 954–959). Praying for the dead, above all by offering Mass, has been Christian practice from the earliest times (CCC 1032; 2 Macc 12:46).
Claims checked
- ‘Halloween’ means the eve of All Hallows (All Saints).Recorded
- Gregory IV extended a 1 November All Saints feast across the Frankish lands in 835.Recorded
- The Church chose 1 November to replace the Celtic Samhain.Legend
- Some Halloween folk customs drew on older seasonal traditions.Plausible
- All Souls’ Day began with Odilo of Cluny around 998.Recorded
Sources to check
- Online Etymology Dictionary, ‘Halloween’Shows ‘Halloween’ is a Scottish shortening of ‘All Hallows’ Even’, the eve of All Saints.
- Liber Pontificalis, lives of Boniface IV and Gregory III (Catholic Encyclopedia, ‘All Saints’ Day’)secondaryRecords the Pantheon dedication to all the martyrs and Gregory III’s All Saints chapel.
- UCD Cultural Heritage Collections, ‘A Season for Saints and the Supernatural’ (on the Martyrology of Tallaght and Félire Óengusso)Explains the early Irish calendars, with all the saints of Europe on 20 April.
- Ronald Hutton, The Stations of the Sun (1996)Historian’s study of the ritual year, questioning the Samhain origin of All Saints.
- Odilo of Cluny, statute on the commemoration of the dead (Catholic Encyclopedia, ‘All Souls’ Day’)secondaryOdilo’s instruction to pray for all the faithful departed on 2 November, the origin of All Souls.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 954–959, 1030–1032The communion of saints, purification after death, and prayer for the dead.
- 2 Maccabees 12:46Atonement offered for the dead.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
The Church chose 1 November for All Saints in order to replace the Celtic festival of Samhain.
Show the answer
Myth. The 1 November date was set in Rome and the Frankish empire; early Irish calendars kept a feast of all the saints of Europe in April.