Bite-size Formation

The Eleventh Hour

How the Church keeps time

The Eleventh Hour › Bite 24 of 34 · 2 min read

Why Shrove Tuesday means pancakes

Confession, pancakes and a ‘fat Tuesday’ on the eve of the fast.

First recorded: c. 1000. Roots: Confession before Lent; Lent’s old ban on meat, eggs and dairy
In the week: Shrove Tuesday: the eve of Ash Wednesday
In the year: Shrove Tuesday (the day before Ash Wednesday)

Ask what the day before Ash Wednesday is called and the answer depends on where you grew up: Shrove Tuesday, Pancake Day, Mardi Gras. Each name tells part of its story. Because Ash Wednesday moves with Easter, so does Shrove Tuesday; it always falls 47 days before Easter Sunday.

Start with the English name. ‘Shrove’ comes from the old verb ‘to shrive’, meaning to hear someone’s confession and give absolution. Around the year 1000, Abbot Ælfric’s English version of a church rulebook told everyone to go to their confessor in the week before Lent, confess, and receive a penance to carry through the fast. The English name, in other words, is about preparing the soul.

Then the food. For centuries Lent ruled out not only meat but eggs, butter and other animal products. Households used them up before the fast began, which is why England made pancakes, the French called the day Mardi gras, ‘Fat Tuesday’, and the Germans Fastnacht, the ‘eve of the fast’. The same ban helps explain why eggs return so triumphantly at Easter. (The full story belongs to the food-and-drink series.)

And carnival? The word comes through Italian carnevale from carne levare, ‘taking away the meat’, the putting aside of flesh as Lent begins. The popular explanation, carne vale, ‘farewell, flesh!’, is a later folk etymology. Carnival seasons can stretch for weeks; New Orleans counts from Twelfth Night. The Church repeatedly tried, with mixed success, to rein in carnival’s excesses.

Here is the quirk: Shrove Tuesday is not a feast in the Church’s calendar at all. Liturgically it is an ordinary weekday of Ordinary Time. Its customs are folk preparations for Lent, which begins the next morning. In Australia it lands in late summer, so the pancakes come with heat rather than snow.

Why it matters

Shrovetide’s original point, confession before Lent, still stands. Lent is the Church’s privileged time of conversion (CCC 1438), and the sacrament of Penance is at its heart: reconciliation with God and with the Church (CCC 1422, 1440). The pancakes are fun; the shriving was the point.

Claims checked

Sources to check

Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.

Myth or fact?

The word ‘carnival’ comes from the Latin for ‘farewell, meat’.

Show the answer

Myth. It comes from carne levare, ‘taking away the meat’; ‘farewell, flesh’ is a later folk etymology.