Three days in a day and a half
Inclusive counting, Queen Esther, and ‘on the third day’.
Every Easter someone does the maths. Jesus died on Friday afternoon and rose before dawn on Sunday. That is not much more than a day and a half. So how is it ‘on the third day’, as the Creed says, and how does it square with Jesus’ own comparison to Jonah, ‘three days and three nights in the belly of the whale’ (Mt 12:40)?
The answer is that the ancient world counted inclusively. Any part of a day counted as a day. Friday was day one, Saturday day two, Sunday day three. The Bible does this elsewhere. Queen Esther asks her people to fast ‘for three days, night or day’, and then goes to the king ‘on the third day’ (Est 4:16; 5:1), not on the fourth. A later rabbinic saying, attributed to Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah around AD 100, puts the rule plainly: a day and a night make one unit of time, and part of that unit counts as the whole (Jerusalem Talmud, Shabbat 9:3).
The New Testament is consistent about this. Paul, writing around AD 55, hands on the tradition that Christ ‘was raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures’ (1 Cor 15:4). And on Easter Sunday afternoon, the disciples walking to Emmaus say that ‘it is now the third day since this happened’ (Lk 24:21). Sunday is the third day; the count started on Friday.
Some writers have tried to fit a full seventy-two hours by moving the crucifixion to a Wednesday or Thursday. But Mark is clear that Jesus died on ‘the day of Preparation, that is, the day before the sabbath’ (Mk 15:42), and a Wednesday death would make Sunday the fifth day, not the third.
The Church’s liturgy still counts this way. The Easter Triduum, the ‘three days’, begins with the evening Mass of the Lord’s Supper on Thursday and ends with Evening Prayer on Easter Sunday (Universal Norms 19). Three days, counted from sunset to sunset, just as the first bite in this series would lead you to expect.
Why it matters
‘On the third day’ is in the Creed because it was in the earliest Christian preaching (1 Cor 15:3–4). The phrase anchors the Resurrection in real time: a real death, a real burial, a real dawn. The Catechism insists that the Resurrection is a real event, with manifestations that were historically verified (CCC 639), and notes that Christ’s body lay in the tomb without seeing corruption (CCC 627). Each year the Triduum lets the Church walk through those same three days.
Claims checked
- Scripture uses ‘for three days’ and ‘on the third day’ for the same span (Esther 4:16; 5:1).Recorded
- A rabbinic rule counted part of a day as the whole day.Recorded
- The disciples on Easter Sunday call it ‘the third day’ (Lk 24:21).Recorded
- The Gospels require a full 72 hours in the tomb.False
Sources to check
- Matthew 12:40; Esther 4:16; 5:1Jesus’ ‘three days and three nights’ saying, and Esther’s fast ending ‘on the third day’.
- 1 Corinthians 15:4; Luke 24:21; Mark 15:42‘On the third day’, ‘the third day since this happened’, and the crucifixion on the day before the Sabbath.
- Jerusalem Talmud, Shabbat 9:3Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah’s rule that part of a day-and-night counts as the whole.
- Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year and the Calendar (1969), n. 19Defines the Triduum as running from Thursday evening to Evening Prayer on Easter Sunday.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 627, 639Christ’s real death and burial, and the Resurrection as a real, historical event.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
To count as ‘three days’, Jesus had to be in the tomb for a full 72 hours.
Show the answer
Myth. The ancients counted inclusively: Friday, Saturday and Sunday are three days. Luke 24:21 calls Sunday ‘the third day’.