Bite-size Formation

The Eleventh Hour

How the Church keeps time

The Eleventh Hour › Bite 4 of 34 · 2 min read

Why Christians fasted on Wednesdays and Fridays

The first Christian fast days, and the origin of ‘When in Rome’.

First recorded: c. 100. Roots: Jewish fasting on Mondays and Thursdays (Lk 18:12)
In the week: Early Christian fast day (Didache 8); Fast day; still a day of penance

Imagine being a Christian in Syria around the year 100, reading your church’s handbook, the Didache. It gives a surprisingly specific instruction: do not fast with the hypocrites, who fast on Monday and Thursday; fast instead on Wednesday and Friday (Didache 8.1). Devout Jews of the time fasted twice a week, on Mondays and Thursdays. The Pharisee in Jesus’ parable boasts about exactly this (Lk 18:12). The first Christians kept the habit but changed the days.

Why Wednesday and Friday? Friday is obvious: the day of the Crucifixion. Later writers explain Wednesday as the day Judas agreed to betray Jesus. That reasoning may be the original one, or it may be a later explanation for an existing custom, so it earns a Plausible. These fasts were called ‘station days’, a military image found in the Shepherd of Hermas and in Tertullian: Christians standing guard, like soldiers on watch.

Rome added a twist: it also fasted on Saturdays. When St Augustine’s mother, Monica, moved to Milan, she was puzzled to find the church there did not fast on Saturday. Which custom should she follow? She asked Bishop Ambrose, who replied that when he was in Rome he fasted on Saturday, and when he was in Milan he did not. Follow the custom of the church where you are. Augustine records the exchange in his letters (Letters 36 and 54), and it is the ancestor of our proverb ‘When in Rome, do as the Romans do’.

Today the Eastern Churches still keep both Wednesday and Friday as fast days. In the Latin Church, canon law makes every Friday a day of penance (can. 1250), with abstinence from meat unless the bishops’ conference allows another form of penance (cann. 1251, 1253). Australia’s bishops did exactly that in 1985. Here, fasting and abstinence are required only on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday; on every other Friday of the year, including the Fridays of Lent, Catholics may choose another form of penance, such as prayer, self-denial or helping others.

So the humble Friday fish dinner belongs to a habit older than most of the New Testament canon.

Why it matters

Friday penance is not a dietary rule but a weekly remembrance of the Crucifixion. The Catechism names ‘each Friday in memory of the death of the Lord’ among the Church’s times of penance (CCC 1438), and canon law makes every Friday a penitential day (can. 1250). Fasting, prayer and almsgiving together express conversion in relation to God, to oneself and to others (CCC 1434).

Claims checked

Sources to check

Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.

Myth or fact?

The saying ‘When in Rome, do as the Romans do’ goes back to St Ambrose’s advice about fasting.

Show the answer

Fact. Augustine records Ambrose’s advice in Letters 36 and 54. The modern wording came later.