When the Easter Vigil was held at breakfast
“This is the night,” sung in broad daylight.
Picture a parish church in 1950. It is Holy Saturday, a little after breakfast. The new fire is struck in broad daylight, and the deacon sings the Exsultet’s great refrain: “This is the night.” Today that would be unthinkable. The rubrics require the whole Easter Vigil to take place at night, beginning after nightfall and ending before daybreak on Sunday (Roman Missal, Easter Vigil, n. 3). There is no such thing as an early-bird Easter Vigil, however tempting it might be for the choir.
That rule is a return to the beginning. Augustine called this night the ‘mother of all holy vigils’ (Sermon 219). The early Church kept watch through the whole night, baptised its catechumens, and broke the Lenten fast at dawn with the Eucharist. Tertullian, around 200, even warns a Christian woman against marrying a pagan, since what husband would tolerate his wife being out all night at the Easter celebrations? (To His Wife 2.4).
Then the vigil drifted. Over the Middle Ages it was celebrated earlier and earlier: in the evening, then the afternoon, then the morning of Holy Saturday. Fasting rules, practical convenience and later rubrics that kept Mass to the morning hours all pushed in the same direction. By early modern times the morning Vigil was simply what everyone knew, sunlight and all.
Pius XII changed that. In 1951 he allowed the Vigil to be restored to the night as an experiment. It worked so well that in 1955 the decree Maxima Redemptionis nostrae mysteria reformed the whole of Holy Week, and from 1956 the night Vigil became the norm everywhere. The 1988 circular letter on the Easter feasts repeated the point firmly: a Vigil that begins before dark is reprehensible (Paschalis Sollemnitatis 78).
In Australia, where Easter falls in autumn, sunset comes early enough to start at a civilised hour. Elsewhere, choirs in high summer are not so lucky.
Why it matters
The Vigil is the ‘mother of all vigils’ because in it Christ’s Passover is made present. In the liturgy, the events of salvation are not only remembered but become present (CCC 1104, 1363). That is why the Exsultet sings ‘This is the night’, not ‘that was the night’. It is also the Church’s great night of baptism, when the baptismal water is blessed with the story of salvation (CCC 1217).
Claims checked
- The early Church kept the Easter vigil through the night.Recorded
- For centuries before the 1950s the Vigil was held on Holy Saturday morning.Recorded
- Pius XII restored the Vigil to the night (1951 trial, 1955 reform).Recorded
- The Easter Vigil may begin before sunset if that suits the parish.False
Sources to check
- Augustine, Sermon 219 (quoted in the Universal Norms, n. 21)secondaryAugustine calls the Easter Vigil the ‘mother of all holy vigils’.
- Tertullian, To His Wife 2.4Tertullian (c. 200) assumes Christians spent the whole Easter night at church.
- Sacred Congregation of Rites, Maxima Redemptionis nostrae mysteria (1955) (summarised in the 1988 Easter circular letter)secondaryThe 1955 Holy Week reform that returned the Vigil to the night everywhere.
- Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year and the Calendar (1969), n. 21Calendar law: the Vigil must take place at night, beginning after nightfall.
- Congregation for Divine Worship, Paschalis Sollemnitatis (1988), n. 78Vatican letter on Easter that calls a Vigil begun before dark an abuse.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 1104, 1217, 1363Liturgy as memorial that makes the paschal mystery present; baptism at the Easter Vigil.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
Before the 1950s, the Easter Vigil was normally celebrated on Holy Saturday morning.
Show the answer
Fact. It had drifted to the morning over the Middle Ages; Pius XII restored it to the night.