Bite-size Formation

The Eleventh Hour

How the Church keeps time

The Eleventh Hour › Bite 31 of 34 · 2 min read

Why Saturday evening counts

An ancient instinct, a very modern permission.

First recorded: 1967. Roots: Evening Prayer I of Sunday; evening Masses permitted from 1953
On the clock: 17:30 Saturday evening Mass
In the week: Saturday evening already belongs to Sunday

Ask around the parish why Saturday evening Mass ‘counts’ for Sunday and you will usually hear: “Because the Jewish day starts at sunset.” It is a lovely answer, and it is about half right.

The liturgical logic is real. As bite 1 showed, Sunday’s celebration begins with Evening Prayer I on Saturday evening. But for most of the Church’s history there was simply no such thing as an evening Mass. Under the rubrics in force for centuries, Mass was ordinarily celebrated between dawn and midday, and the Eucharistic fast from midnight made an evening Communion close to impossible anyway. Nobody in 1850 went to the 6 pm vigil, because there wasn’t one.

Change came in the twentieth century, for very practical reasons. Shift work, long commutes and wartime disruption meant many Catholics could not get to a morning Mass. In 1953 Pius XII’s Christus Dominus allowed bishops to permit evening Masses where there was real pastoral need, and in 1957 he widened the permission. Through the 1960s the Holy See began granting particular countries leave to fulfil the Sunday obligation on Saturday evening, and the 1967 instruction Eucharisticum Mysterium (n. 28) told pastors in those places how to explain it. A general permission for bishops followed in 1970 and was renewed in 1974 and 1979. Finally, the 1983 Code of Canon Law made it universal: the obligation is satisfied by assisting at Mass celebrated in a Catholic rite either on the holy day itself or on the evening of the preceding day (can. 1248 §1).

Read that canon slowly and two quirks appear. First, it says ‘in a Catholic rite’, so a Divine Liturgy in an Eastern Catholic church counts just as much as the Roman Rite. Second, it does not say ‘the Mass of Sunday’. Canonists generally agree that a Saturday evening wedding Mass, with its own readings, fulfils the obligation too. And ‘evening’ is never defined; local custom usually treats late afternoon onwards as evening.

So the vigil Mass stands on two legs. One is very old: the conviction that the great days begin at dusk. The other is very new: a Church deciding, in the spirit of Mark 2:27, that the Sabbath was made for people and not people for the Sabbath.

Why it matters

The vigil Mass is not a convenience Mass in disguise. John Paul II insisted that it is in effect the festive Mass of Sunday, with homily and prayer of the faithful (Dies Domini 49), because the obligation exists for the sake of the Sunday assembly. The Sunday Eucharist, says the Catechism, is the foundation and confirmation of all Christian practice (CCC 2181).

Claims checked

Sources to check

Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.

Myth or fact?

The Saturday evening ‘vigil’ Mass has fulfilled the Sunday obligation since the early Church.

Show the answer

Myth. Evening Masses were only permitted from 1953, and anticipated Sunday Masses spread in the 1960s.