Why Christmas has three Masses
Night, dawn and day, and a pope walking across Rome.
Turn to Christmas in the Roman Missal and you will find not one Mass but three complete sets of texts: the Mass during the Night, the Mass at Dawn and the Mass during the Day. Every priest may celebrate all three. Christmas shares that privilege with just one other day, All Souls (2 November), which Benedict XV granted in 1915.
The custom grew up in Rome. By the sixth century the pope celebrated at night at St Mary Major, which treasured relics of the Bethlehem manger. At dawn he went to the church of St Anastasia, a martyr whose feast fell on 25 December and whose church served the Greek-speaking imperial quarter, an early piece of diplomatic courtesy. During the day he celebrated at St Peter’s. Pope Gregory the Great, preaching at Christmas in 591, mentions that ‘we are to celebrate Mass three times today’.
Why at night at all? Luke’s shepherds keep watch by night (Lk 2:8), and the liturgy of the Christmas season borrows a line from Wisdom 18:14–15: when all things were in quiet silence and night was in the midst of its course, your almighty Word leapt down from heaven. That passage originally described the Passover night in Egypt. In the liturgy it belongs not to Midnight Mass but to the Sunday within the Christmas octave in the older Missal, and to the Second Sunday after Christmas today. The idea that Jesus was actually born at midnight comes from devotion, not from the Gospels.
Medieval writers found a deeper meaning in the three Masses: the Son’s eternal birth from the Father, his birth in time from Mary, and his birth in the hearts of believers. Aquinas repeats this (ST III, q. 83, a. 2). It is a beautiful reading, but it came after the custom, not before it.
One last quirk. The current English Missal calls it the Mass ‘during the Night’, and many parishes hold their ‘Midnight Mass’ in the late evening. That is common practice, though a Vatican reply in 1974 urged that this Mass be celebrated around midnight so that it is authentic as to time. So if your parish’s ‘Midnight Mass’ starts at 10 pm, it is in good company, but the purists have a point.
Why it matters
However the custom began, the three Masses invite reflection on Christ’s threefold ‘birth’: eternally from the Father, in time from Mary, and by grace in the hearts of believers (Aquinas, ST III, q. 83, a. 2). The night Mass proclaims light in darkness, ‘The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light’ (Is 9:2), the heart of the mystery that the Word became flesh (Jn 1:14; CCC 525–526).
Claims checked
- By Gregory the Great’s time the pope celebrated three Masses at Christmas.Recorded
- The dawn Mass was linked to the church and feast of St Anastasia.Recorded
- Jesus was born at midnight.Legend
- The three Masses were created to symbolise three ‘births’ of Christ.Plausible
- Christmas is the only day a priest may celebrate three Masses.False
Sources to check
- Gregory the Great, Homilies on the Gospels 1.8 (Homily 7 in Hurst’s English translation) (Latin opening, as read at Christmas Matins)Gregory’s Christmas sermon of 591, opening with the remark that Mass will be celebrated three times that day.
- Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year and the Calendar (1969), n. 34, with the 1974 reply on the Mass at Midnight (note R6)The calendar norms on Christmas’s three Masses, plus a 1974 Vatican reply that the Mass at Midnight should be near midnight.
- Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae III, q. 83, a. 2Aquinas’s explanation of the three Masses as Christ’s threefold birth, written centuries after the custom began.
- Benedict XV, Incruentum Altaris (1915) (Diocese of Westminster, ‘Three Masses on All Souls’ Day’)secondaryThe 1915 grant allowing every priest three Masses on All Souls’ Day, the only other such day.
- Isaiah 9:2The first reading at the Mass during the Night: light in darkness.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 525–526The mystery of Christmas.
Linked sources open a free online text in a new tab; ‘secondary’ marks a free account of a source whose own text isn’t freely online. Scripture links use the RSVCE.
Myth or fact?
Christmas is the only day of the year on which a priest may celebrate three Masses.
Show the answer
Myth. All Souls’ Day (2 November) has the same privilege, granted by Benedict XV in 1915.